To Click or not to Click
Tuesday, August 24th, 2010I had a really interesting conversation with a drummer friend of mine last week about playing with a click track, and it inspired me to write a little ditty about it. He basically said that he wasn’t being asked to play in church as frequently because he was having trouble staying with the click track. Now I won’t agree that this is a wise way for churches to choose their players, but without going into a huge rant about church “auditions” I’ll just keep it here, and talk about how to getting better with a click track for those of you that are struggling with it. Here the top reasons why drummers struggle with the click track.
- They don’t practice with a click.
A lot of guys will practice all day long with no click track, and then expect that when one is turned on, they’ll just get it. It definitely doesn’t work that way at all. Playing to a click is something that takes practice on it’s own much like drumming itself, you can get sloppy if you stay away from it for a while. So first off, if you aren’t practicing to a click change that now and within a few weeks you’ll be 100 times better.
I’d recommend playing very simple beats and fills to a click, see where you’re struggling, if you’re good on your own you’ll be able to help drive a band much better. This will also drastically improve your time when the click isn’t running. Trust me, you’ll quickly see where you struggle. Ever hear a song take off on that big drum fill, big cymbal crash at the end and then the band follows about a split second later, that’s a symptom of no click that needs to be resolved if you wanna work, or play at church in this case.
- You can’t hear the click.
If the click is the last thing you put in your ears it’ll get buried, and your overall volume will be too loud to compensate. Make sure the drums are all good in your ears, get the click set now with your drums playing, than add in the other players on top of the bottom you’ve created. If anything interferes with the click, take that instrument down so you have click on the higher side of your mix. As you get better with the click you can lower the volume down a lot, but when you’re starting out, keep it hotter than you think you’d like, trust me you’ll be thankful when everything kicks in.
The goal here is that eventually the click is pretty low in your mix. That way you can make it sound and feel better by moving in and out of the click, the difference here is that you’re practiced so much that you’re doing it on purpose. In the early stages keep the click loud.
- You have the wrong subdivisions.
If you’re playing a song at 65bpm with a quarter note click you’re going to get lost. The longer between clicks the more likely you, or someone else, will get off the click. Keep it 8th notes as long as you can stand it. I always prefer the quarter notes to be accented, but just anything but a straight quarter will help you out a lot. For 6/8 tunes or other odd time you have to figure out what works for you, but generally I’ll still keep 8ths as much as I can.
- The other players are off.
This is a tough one to swallow, but if the other guys are getting off the click when you are playing, and it’s pushing you around, you are failing at your job. You are the captain of the ship, you have to push the other players where you wanna go. If they are dropping time when you aren’t playing a full groove, keep time with you hat or your ride during the down sections. That way they are still listening to you. That will teach the band to listen back to the drums and will cause them to tighten up to you, and if you’re tight to the click, you have a tight band.
Playing with a click is the #1 way to tighten up a band and as drummers are really do need to be prepared for this. Modern music is almost always cut to a click track which means the days of winging it live are over. We are always going to emulate recorded music when we play live, so if the music we are emulating is very tight and accurate, we’re going to need to replicate that when we are playing the songs live. As music changes so must we or we’ll get left behind.
So, though I don’t agree that falling off the click is a good reason to replace a drummer at a church service, in the professional music world it’s going to create a huge problem if you’re looking for work. So woodshed with that click running all the time and get used to it. Think of it like a very comfortable blanket that you take with you everywhere and I bet the gig callbacks will go up. Good luck, click click click click click peeps!
